It has been a black day today. As visuals and news about the siege at Mumbai’s hotels permeates through my living room, I am filled with despair and sadness. Sadness; for all the mindless tragedy that is unfolding, for all the innocent people held hostage, for the families of our police officers, the celebrated faces as well as the unknown men who have been matyred.
Terrorism is hateful and terrorists are the scum of the earth. I find it hard to conceive what drives these men, what ideologies they believe and live by. To see young men so blinded by religious hate and bigotry , stooping to such cold-blooded, planned, mass murder is scary as well as shocking. Honestly, I am myself surprised by my irrational sadness and fear. It isn’t as if Mumbai is new to terrorist attacks-we have had enough of them in the past too…I think the answer lies in the “we have had enough” phrase, in the sense of déjà vu’, the sense of hopelessness. Truly, in this case, familiarity doesn’t breed contempt: familiarity breeds fear.
News channels have said it’s the worse attack in India till date. Though they were speaking in terms of numbers, I somehow feel that the psychology of it hurts even more. It was an attack which began at night and then it raged on throughout the night when people were unaware and blissfully asleep. I feel guilty about dismissing the initial reports as hyperbole, for believing that things would settle down in an hour or two with some expendable collateral damage. I feel guilty that while such happenings were unfolding outside, I was cooped up all-night within the closed air-conditioned confines of my room, more bothered with trying to tick off ‘Topics to be read” on my list for my exam. It was only when my Mom woke up at 3.30 a.m to see the TV and as news of deaths of the ATS chief himself along with other key aides filtered through; I realized the enormity and the scale of the attacks. While I swotted, Mumbai burnt.
I feel bad for the families of the police officers. Nobody could have ever imagined that a response to a late-night distress call could have such horrific circumstances. It was only yesterday morning that I had seen Hemant Karkare speaking to the media and then to know 24 hours later of his death was disturbing, to say the least. Same holds true for the deaths of the other top-brass. These were men, highly trained and highly reputed and if they could be shot down like that, then it underlines how even more vulnerable we all are.
The hotel Taj has always been a landmark of Mumbai. Many people, including my relatives from Orissa on coming down here, in the early Nineties, would go to see the Gateway and then marvel at the hotel Taj. People have been known to sit in the till-now free-for-all lobby of the Taj, gape, gawk and then go back home with stars in their eyes. The Taj has always been synonymous with the glamour and allure of Mumbai. But as the dome of the Taj burnt, as smoke and dust swirled around, it metaphorically seemed as if even my hopes and dreams were being reduced to ashes.
Yes, Mumbai has always been the city of dreams. 22 years ago when my Mom came to the city as a new bride from a small town in Orissa, she was considered lucky by most friends and well-wishers. But now, most parents have become wary of sending kids here, partly due to the attacks and partly due to MNS propanganda ( But let me not digress into that story). People have always emigrated with high hopes to this city, believing nothing is impossible but this has virtually been a death-knell for us. As Sonia Gandhi has put it rightly, ‘It’s not only about security, it’s also about prestige”. I think the usual noises will be made about “the spirit of Mumbai” and all that but I think it is all pure bullshit now. I think, this time, average Mumbaikars like me have been tested beyond the limits of endurance.
Politicians have started descending like vultures, making the right noises at the wrong time as usual. But frankly the security lapses are deplorable. This isn’t the first time nor will it be the last time. These terrorists crossed the international borders at the sea unintercepted and they sailed right below the noses of the Coast Guards and the Navy undetected to arrive at the Gateway. This only highlights the loopholes and the deficiencies that exist in our border patrolling and the entry-exit checkpoints into the country. If exclusive places like the Taj and the Trident with their well-oiled security mechanisms could have been rendered so vulnerable to infiltration and internal attacks, then spare a thought for the other rowdy, crowded public places in Mumbai. And to add salt to our wounds, we have e-mails from these terror outfits mocking our inefficiency and the bitter reality that “the Army and ATS do not have the weaponry to deal with ours sophisticated weapons”.
Now I am not an analyst. I don’t know and neither want to know the hows and whys of these attacks, the funding, the finances, the brains and the technicalities. All I care for as an ordinary self-respectable citizen, is an assurance of safety, the right to live without fear and the right to plan for innocuous things like an exam-ending celebration, a lunch date, a movie outing with friends and other such simple pleasures.
But is wishful thinking right? Because it is a war brewing out there right now. No easy solutions and no easy answers. In the last hour or so that I’ve spent typing this out, the situation outside still remains unchanged like over the past 24 hours…everything is in a limbo while we wait for a reasonable resolution with bated breaths and anxious eyes. In the meantime, there’s nothing much we can do except hope and pray, wait and watch…
All of you, reading this keep your fingers crossed and be safe…Take care and God bless.
P.S. Please think b4 u comment
Thursday, November 27, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
13 comments:
Dont you get the hopeless feeling that we're all just living from one crisis to the next here and that the much talked about spirit of Mumbai, is barely more than sheer resignation about getting down to the business of going back to work?
And every time a new crisis happens, our fear either changes form or holds onto us tighter..
I used to be afraid of boarding trains before, and now I am afraid of hanging out at Causeway and Marine Drive after hours now..
I internally nod at every sentence you've written becoz I feel so damn guilty now that a lot of what I was worried about was the status of our exam and relieved at the thought that it happened on the night of the 26th and not on the night of the 27th when we wud have been out celebrating end of exams..
Exactly...the drama is unfolding out at areas which are at a stone throw from the institutions of power, the symbols of democracy-the Mantralaya, the naval colony, the Express towers, the causeway...this attack is worse than the sudden sound and fury of bomb blasts, the long drawn vigil is as painful as it is mind-numbing.
Yes, we are stuck in limbo, thats the perfect word, not in hell exactly, not much better than that either.
And Mr. Hemant Karkare, sent to take bullets on his chest, in that flimsy green excuse of a bullet proof jacket that was sure to let bullets thru..
if we forget this, and get on with our lives, then we deserve what we get, if a country does not reward valour and immortalise its heroes, then it will always be an easy target.
More and more on this, more reviews, more analysis will add to the misery.
As the agencies will probe, much more heinous thought processes behind the attack will be known to us.
Too depressed to write further.
I think this is the first time, that people are actually scared. I am far away cooped up in navi mumbai, and its so disturbing. I never thought i would see commandos being air-dropped and patrolling our streets.
And the another issue here, why were the foriengers targetted so specifically? It is as if the terrorists have made a point. Not just the common man on the road, but the elite of the society is just as vulnerable.
I think if things continue like this, the army will have to not just patrol the country's borders but also the urban perimeters.
I hope there are no more casualties.
and I cannot begin to imagine the grief of the families of our officers who lost their lives.
Dat was indeed an excellent way in which u summed up the entire scenario
but it lukd realy monotonous..every other editorial afer every attack possibly carries same stuff
i would like to draw ur attention to a more deeper underlying fact
'FEAR" u said...v wud hve been really lucky had dat feeling of fear cum 2 our mind..sadly it doesnt...v r no more afraid but v hve subconsciously considered dat 2 b part of our life..jst a matter of few weeks and everything will b same 4 us again...may it b CST station...leopold cafe...or TAJ and OBEROI
"GUILT"...u said ,by worrying about nxt day exam more than the attacks...i dunt think most of us wud feel so...and world arnd us is 2 b blamed..i was vey well aware dat this incident wud be forgotten few weeks down the line...but our performance in dis exam wud b sumthing dat the world arnd us wud b more bothered about.
The reason for the above 2 points i made is dat v hve subconsciously stopped taking these attacks seriously or seriously enough
We are more happy and feel genuinely proud dat our armed forces "killed"..sum terrorists who had practically "finished" their task of destruction & who had come wid purpose of dying after 60 hrs.v will feel proud as indians and get on wid our lives till it is finished 1 day by 1 such terrorist attack.wats the use of having such a huge army wen u cant do anything even after knowing where the culprits are from?
Look at USA on other hand
2 buildings brought 2 ashes..
in retaliation 2 culprit countries were brought 2 ashes and still counting
7 yrs on not a single american has died in any terrorist attack in america...
dats the thing 1 shud b proud of.
this happened bcoz USA govt as well as pple were gripped by "FEAR"...they took dat very "SERIOUSLY"..
It was a very well thought and well written article i must say and must compliment u for dat as well..but unfortunately no purpose wud b served by writing such articles esp for such pple and such govt who do nuthing but just marvel at the everincreasing power and audacity of such terrorists..and in the end feel extremely proud by making a standard statement
"Salute to Spirit of Mumbai"
For once i wish we could all shut up and pray for strength for the families of those departed and salute the NSG, army and the Mumbai police, instead of trying to hog the limelight ourselves (including us, with our comments and the politicians).
-Shraddha
I completely agree with shraddha.
We need to just shut up. We are as foolish as anyone else.
OK the last comment on this issue for once and all...
Probably i have seemed too verbose to u but frankly, the best way for me to deal with any incident or happening, is to put it in words, to express it out and the blog semed as a good a forum as any.
This blog was a purely instinctive reaction, a gut reaction and not a publicity stunt. I think, once u've had ur say, the process of healing begins.
But its been nice to hear the feedback...
Ok, so time for me to shut up.
Tc and Gb
i didn't say anyone specifically (or you ananya) was too verbose.
It was just a reaction to something i saw on tv...there is this female bachi k, who writes a column in the Indian Express every sunday. According to her, it was a common person which was affected in this attack, somebody's family member, somebody's friend. And then there were the agitated reactions of so many celebs on tv.
The thing that enraged me is (and i know that this is no time for divisive sentiments), why has this rage come so late? the mumbai train blasts happened. Terrorism in Mumbai had to stop then. And that BAchi female...were the people who died in the train blast not family/ friends of someone.
So this 'talking' of people enraged me.
Also, today morning i read in the paper that the NSG had problems because the terrorists came to know of their positions via live telecasts of the tv channels. Though I must admit, i myself was glued to the live coverage, I am so irritated with the idiotic tv channel heads. we are not that desperate to watch the live coverage. the work of the NSG should have been given top priority.
Anyways, i think i have said too much. But i had to, since Ananya seemed offended.
-Shraddha
hey ppl come on... With so much happening around there are going to be differences of opinion somewhere or the other.
The reason behind our outburst was that many columnists (including Bachi) have written pages of crap. Everyday Bombay Times carries this "What Mumbai is asking" kind of shit. I mean, we need to be united now and media (including bloggers and opinion-wallahs) must behave responsibly. Times Now is one news channel that has excellent coverage and talks very responsibly.
What we need is not prescription but surgery. If someone expects we as individuals to do something, then its too late now. We are now facing professional killers who cannot be tackled by anyone other than the likes of the NSG.
Nothing in the post/comments is offensive to anyone and I'm sure no one is offended.
Definitely..i agree wid Ani...everyone has and should have his/her opinion and i wud be a fool if i were to take offence over such trivial things... at the end of the day, blogging is ultimately a form of self-expression only...comments r just an icing on the cake :-)
"I don't know and don't want to know whys and hows of these attacks...All I care for is...the assurance of safety, right to live without fear..."
My commenting here could be too late, but your comment above is like a malaria patient saying "I don't want to know of how I contracted malaria, but all I want is I never suffer from it again".
Of course, I've oversimplified too much by this analogy since even by knowing the cause of these attacks and their funding, we won't be able to do much.
All this money comes from three major sources--petroleum, narcotic drugs and selling and smuggling weapons. The last is not a real source since the money is merely transferred from one Muslim nation to another. Their real income is money that comes from nonMuslim nations--the Western countries and countries like India.
So, each time a government somewhere by way of erecting bureaucratic roadblocks (inadequate funding included) is not allowing innovation of new sources (other than petroleum products) of power generation, it is promoting such attacks. Each time parents in their frenzy of earning money forget to give quality time to their kids, and when they turn to drugs, promote such attacks.
I'm an atheist, and it pains me so much to realize for I can see it so clearly that each time we attach glory to invisible things, we promote such attacks.
I'd written the following post in response to the Mumbai attack (don't go by the date of its publication), do see if I'm making sense through it:
http://ketanpanchal.blogspot.com/2009/03/communalism.html
Well written!
Take care.
Post a Comment